The Mimicking of Known Successes: an investigation over tea

Malka Older

Pleiti wants to return to her studies. Instead, Mossa is waiting at the station: an investigator, a former girlfriend, and someone whose arrival makes an ordinary offer of tea difficult to read. Pleiti can hear the request for professional help; she is less sure what the visit might mean for the two of them.

Read this? Find your next book

Part of a seriesShortPace: Brisk

Editorial estimate, not an exact measurement

A familiar face in unfamiliar weather

A storm rocks the railcar as Pleiti reaches Valdegeld University. She delights in the old buildings and searches the platform for a seam left by a salvaged satellite. Mossa, standing beside her in the cold, would rather get indoors. The reunion begins with two people looking at the same place and experiencing quite different things.

Pleiti's attachment makes this distant colony feel inhabited. She knows its shops, its awkward routes and its pleasures. Her fondness also slows her attention to her companion. The contrast gives the scene a small, recognizable embarrassment: knowing someone well does not ensure that you are noticing what they need now.

What an invitation might mean

Pleiti takes Mossa to her rooms, where Mossa examines the furnishings and Pleiti immediately reconsiders her own decorating choices. Then comes the reason for the visit: work. Pleiti's questions become sharper. She had almost allowed the meeting to belong to their shared past; Mossa has arrived with a present need.

The first-person narration catches this imbalance without settling Mossa's feelings. We hear Pleiti's hope and irritation, while Mossa remains available only through gestures and speech. A request for help can therefore sound like renewed intimacy and an unwelcome use of old familiarity at once. The conversation keeps both possibilities alive.

The trouble with knowing the best scone

Asked about the missing academic, Bolien Trewl, Pleiti remembers his certainty about which university scones everyone ought to prefer. The recollection makes intellectual arrogance tangible: even another person's taste becomes an opportunity for instruction. Mossa presses her to distinguish whether the man's research matters to him, or whether it mostly makes him important.

Pleiti's dislike becomes information, but it also exposes her expectations of Mossa. She wants the answering joke they once might have shared. Mossa keeps listening as an investigator, and Pleiti resents that professional distance. The evidence-gathering scene gains friction because the person offering useful knowledge also wants something from her listener.

An Earth known through fragments

Pleiti compares faces at the station to petals, then admits that she cannot quite picture petals. Later, the two women argue over what to call the institute that preserves Earth's species. A scholarly metaphor and a quarrel about terminology carry the loss of a world into a conversation that still has room for crumbs and cinnamon.

The publisher explains that Pleiti studies ecosystems from before Earth's collapse as part of an effort towards returning there. Her expertise consequently has a practical burden beyond university prestige. In the passages read, objects and words already show how difficult it is to know a place through what survives of it. The premise gives that difficulty consequences for the investigation.

Two ways into the mystery

Older explains in her essay The First Two Pages that she added a third-person prologue following Mossa to put the mystery before the reunion. Her first version had begun with Pleiti's arrival. That choice gives the two women different narrative positions: the investigator can initially be observed away from the account of the person who knows and misses her.

This is the first volume of The Investigations of Mossa and Pleiti. The opening passages offer their strongest invitation to readers who enjoy conversation doing several jobs at once: testing an account, recalling a relationship and finding reasons to spend another hour together. Readers looking for immediate pursuit may find this opening, with its conversation and emotional hesitation, less inviting. Tea and shelter are pleasures here, but a man's unexplained disappearance includes the possibility of suicide or a fall. The domestic warmth sits close to danger.

Three directions to read next

A Psalm for the Wild-Built · Becky Chambers

Becky Chambers's A Psalm for the Wild-Built also gives hospitality a place in speculative questions: a tea monk meets a robot seeking to understand what people need.

What changes: Its central encounter grows around a question of need. Choose it for that conversation; Older's pair are also testing evidence in a disappearance and negotiating a shared romantic past.

The City & The City · China Miéville

China Miéville's The City & The City follows a murder investigation through an unfamiliar urban arrangement, where knowing how people use a place matters to the case.

What changes: Miéville's premise turns on two cities and the boundaries between them. It offers a police investigation shaped by civic rules, beside Older's university setting and reunion between an investigator and a scholar.

All Systems Red · Martha Wells

Martha Wells's All Systems Red also places a reluctant observer inside a dangerous science-fiction assignment: a self-aware security unit protects a survey team while wanting time for entertainment.

What changes: Its narrator is the security unit itself, with bodily danger and corporate obligations close at hand. Older's opening instead lets the scholar's emotional investment complicate our view of the investigator.

Questions readers ask

Is this the first Mossa and Pleiti book?

Yes. The publisher lists it as volume one of The Investigations of Mossa and Pleiti. The characters' earlier relationship is part of this story's background, rather than a previous volume you must read.

Does Classics mean the same subject as in a present-day university?

Pleiti's Classics concerns Earth before its ecological collapse, including the study of former ecosystems. The opening also distinguishes Classical, Modern and Speculative fields; the familiar academic label belongs to this future society's own divisions of knowledge.

Are the railways and weather part of Earth?

No. The publisher places the human colony on Jupiter, called Giant in the passages. People move between constructed platforms along rail rings, so the storm and the missing man's possible departure over an edge have a different physical setting from an Earthbound campus mystery.

Sources and editorial approach

Direct reading covers Macmillan's public English excerpt: Chapter 1 and the opening of Chapter 2, ending as Mossa and Pleiti prepare to leave the rooms, plus the short prologue passages quoted in Malka Older's own three-page First Two Pages essay. We have not read the whole novella. The essay supplies the author's account of the added prologue; publisher descriptions support the wider premise, series identity and comparisons. Literary interpretations are FolioRoam's.

Find reader reviews

See other readers’ perspectives. Reviews on external sites may cover other editions.

External site; content may be in English.

Search Goodreads for reader reviews